Where there’s paper, there’s ink, and here it’s used both to make naive drawings – a person, a flower, a dog – and to let the bodies and footsteps leave their messier, material imprint upon the rumpled sheet as it variously evokes clothing, sea, an island, giftwrap – or simply paper, marked and creased.
Just as Chinese script is the physical marks of ideas, not sounds, so this performance feels like traces of meanings that lie elsewhere, beyond our grasp. That can make it eerily insubstantial, almost as if it were conjured out of and dissolved back into nothing – yet it is undeniably beautiful, like a few calligraphed stanzas of free verse. —SR
Results, responses
So who won? The Rose prize went to Larsen C by Christos Papadopoulos, the Bloom to Sepia Stav Struz Boutros. No surprise that this engendered some huffing and puffing, as indeed did the whole competition. Was this really the ‘best’ new dance in the world? Who decides? On what basis? Likeability? Innovation? Vision? Execution? Popularity?
The outcome of any vote – as we all know – is at least in part a result of its selection process and election procedure, and in an international field such as this there’s also the sizeable question of cultural differences, both of material conditions and mentality. The question almost asks itself: if it’s that difficult to define a ‘winner’, why have a competition at all?
One answer is: it’s not about the winner. The competition is a means for the field itself to gain an international profile, and for everyone, not just the winners, to ride the swell of its wave. Furthermore, it builds a network of practice, experience and opinion that did not exist before. A whole system gets set up, with the prize serving as its visible face.
That said, I can’t resist giving my own opinion. For the Bloom, I would have been happy for any of the entrants to win – though I wasn’t expecting it to be Sepia, because it fitted no current trend that I know of (it didn’t go down so well with critics I know of, either). For the Rose, I thought Kyle Abraham’s An Untitled Love would win, not necessarily because it was the ‘best’ but because it was, by some distance, the most likeable, even loveable. The other Rose works aimed for more difficult places, tenaciously pushing at their own boundaries even if the results were flawed. In the event, I was happy Papadopoulos won, since the first third of Larsen C (seen from the stalls, not the circle) was my standout moment.
One final thought: nearly everything could benefit from a good edit, because cutting is a vital part of creating, and gives shape to what remains. If you want a prize rose, prune it. —SR